Sunday, November 18, 2012

Sea Oak- critique


George Saunders’s Sea Oak starts with introducing the family this story revolves around. There’s the narrator, who has to strip to earn a living, his sister and cousin who must juggle studying for the GRE, raising two babies, and watching trash TV, and the Aunt. She is made to be the most saintly character in fiction. She’s had a rough life with nothing other than work and taking care of her nieces and nephew. She is a paragon of hope optimism, and then she dies. It is so sudden and out of nowhere that it takes the reader by surprise. Especially when we find out that she was killed by freight. Not the person that robbed her, or the guns that went off what seems like the night before, but being scared by a burglar. But it’s ok because she comes back to life and goes back to the apartment to see her family. 
            Aunt Bernie coming back comes out of nowhere and turns this sadly truthful story into a weird trip. It has great potential for a lot of socio-economic commentary, and some is there. But because it changes genres from realistic drama to horro/sci-fi it takes the reader out of reality and thus undermines it messages.

No comments:

Post a Comment